Playa Betty’s Menu
Playa Betty's, located at 320 Amsterdam Ave in New York, offers a beach-inspired atmosphere with a diverse menu of American, Mexican, and bar favorites. Known for their casual dining experience, Playa Betty's provides options for vegans and vegetarians, along with a range of drink choices. Customers enjoy the vibrant ambiance and hospitable staff, including servers like Joshua who provide attentive service. The menu offers a variety of dishes, from breakfast burritos with crunchy tots to flavorful cauliflower bites. Many patrons recommend trying their popular guacamole and main dishes. Overall, Playa Betty's is praised for its delicious food, relaxed decor, and suitable location for pre-theater dining or brunch outings. With options for outdoor seating, happy hour specials, and accommodating staff, Playa Betty's makes for a memorable dining experience in New York City.
Start Here STARTERS
TOT-CHOS
Tater Tots Topped With Classic Nacho Toppings: Jack Cheese, Guacamole, Sour Cream & Pico De Gallo
SHRIMP CEVICHE
Agua Chile Marinated Shrimp, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Onion, Jalapenos, Cilantro, Fresh Citrus, Pickled Red Onions, Tajin, Tostadas
BUFFALO "CALI" BITES
Cauliflower Served Buffalo Style With Soy Ranch
CRISPY PORK BELLY ADOBO VERDE
Roasted Craclking Pork Belly, Salsa Verde, Poblanos, Jicama Slaw & Fresh Herbs, Choice of Tortillas
BIRIA POUTINE
French Fries, Topped With Braised Short Rib, Queso & Birria Consomme, Cotija, Cilantro
EMPANADAS
Savory Blend Of Monterey Jack, Cheddar, Cream Cheese & Scallions. Served With Guajillo Salsa Roja
NOT "YO" MAMA'S MATZO BALL SOUP
A Rustic Chicken Broth Over Chicken Tinga, Sautéed Jalapenos & Baby Bellas
KALEFORNIA SALAD
Tuscan Kale, Roasted Sweet Potatoes, Farmers Cheese, Pomegranate Seeds, Pepitas, Apple Cider Vinaigrette
GUAC & CHIPS .
Craft Your Own Guacamole By Adding The Ingredients You Like
QUESO & CHIPS
Austin-Style Cheese Dip
HANG
Overstuffed Steak Burrito With Lettuce, Fries, Jack Cheese, Guacamole & Sour Cream
BAJA CRUNCH FRIED FISH
Tempura Black Cod, Spanish Rice, Rainbow Slaw, Pico De Gallo, Red Onion, Guacamole, Spicy Lime Aioli
BEACH BREAK CHICKEN TINGA
Guacamole, Black Beans, Mexican Red Rice, Sour Cream, Lettuce & Cheddar Cheese
SOUL SURFIN’ BURRITOS
Enchiladas
CHICKEN TINGA
Choice Of Sauce: Mo le • Salsa Verde • Salsa Roja • Chili Con Queso
SHORT RIB
Choice Of Sauce: Mo le • Salsa Verde • Salsa Roja • Chili Con Queso
RIB EYE
Choice Of Sauce: Mo le • Salsa Verde • Salsa Roja • Chili Con Queso
VEGANCHILADA
Stewed Seasonal Veg, Roasted Corn, Poblanos, Pico, Vegan Pepper Jack Cheese & Tomatillo Salsa Or Vegie Chili Con Queso
BUILD YOUR OWN Dharma Bowls
Served With Zucchini & Sweet Potato.
CHOOSE A GRAIN
• Brown Rice • Red Quinoa
CHOOSE A GREEN
• Lemony Kale • Spinach • Mixed Greens
CHOOSE A BEAN
• Pinto Beans • Black Beans
CHOOSE A PROTEIN
• Grilled Chicken Breast • Grilled Skirt Steak + • Grilled Tofu (Vegan) • Seared Salmon +
BUILD YOUR OWN Dharma Bowls
TACO TRUCK Tacos
Taco Tuesday!
all day
AL PASTOR
Spit-Grilled Spiced Pork, Onions, Cilantro, Grilled Pineapple, Avocado Tomatillo Salsa
SOUTHERN GIRL
Fried Chicken, Shredded Letuce & Jalapeno Crema, Cotija
SHORT RIB
Beef Short Rib, Pickled Red Onion, Cilantro, Cotija & Chipotle Tomatillo Salsa
BAJA FISH
Tempura Batered Alaskan Cod, Cabbage, Pico, Avocado, Cotija & Jalapeno Crema
I CAN HASS
Tempura Batered Hass Avocado, Letuce & Pico
CARNE ASADA
Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak, Caramelized Onions, Guacamole, Cilantro
THE MARLEY
Jamaican-Style Jerk Chicken, Cabbage, Sweet Plantains, Habanero Salsa
SHROOMS ASADA
Grilled Portabello, Guacamole, Caramelized Onions
SEARED AHI TUNA
Jicama Slaw, Chili-Lime Aioli
Taco Tsunami
Ideal For Table Sharing, Groups Of Or More!
Carne Asada
Chile Poblano Rajas, Griddled Onions, Nopales, Guacamole, Pico De Gallo, Sour Cream, Grilled Limes, Lettuce, Choice Of Flour Or Corn Tortillas
oz Rib Eye
Chile Poblano Rajas, Griddled Onions, Nopales, Guacamole, Pico De Gallo, Sour Cream, Grilled Limes, Lettuce, Choice Of Flour Or Corn Tortillas
Chicken
Chile Poblano Rajas, Griddled Onions, Nopales, Guacamole, Pico De Gallo, Sour Cream, Grilled Limes, Lettuce, Choice Of Flour Or Corn Tortillas
SURF SHACK Fajitas
BIG WAVE Plates
BEACHFIRE CHICKEN
Grilled Chicken Served With Grilled Lime Halves, Grilled Scallions, Corn Tortillas & Mexican Grilled Corn
TACO QUESABIRRIA
Three Braised Short Rib Quesabirria Tacos & Jack Cheese In Corn Tortillas, Served With Birria Consomme, Cilantro, Raw Onion & Lime
CALI CARNITAS
Marinated Braised Pork, Served With Nopales, Black Beans, Brown Rice, Corn Tortillas, Pico De Gallo & Salsa Verde
“PURA VIDA” WHOLE GRILLED FISH
Served With “Santa Fe” Mixed Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Corn, Red Onion, Avocado, Black Beans & Cilantro Lime Vinaigrete
RASTA PASTA
Jamaican Jerk Chicken or Tofu, Julienned Habaneros, Red & Green Peppers, Cherry Tomatoes, Squash, Ezpazote Chile Sauce
CHICKEN MOLE
/ Roasted Bone-In Chicken, Mole Sauce, Served With Flufy Mexican Rice, Black Beans Or Pinto & Your Choice Of Warm Corn Or Flour Tortillas
GRILLED ASPARAGUS
FRIED BRUSSELS SPROUTS
QUESO CON CHILE, MAC N CHEESE
ESQUITES
Mexican Street Corn Off The Cob Topped With Chili Lime Aioli, Cotija & Tajin
ON THE SIDE
More on back!
Try Our Famous Frozen Paloma!
Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver, Grapefruit, Lime & A Pink Peppercorn-Salt Rim
FROZEN PALOMA
Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver, Grapefruit, Lime & A Pink Peppercorn Salt Rim
BETTY'S MARGARITA
Our Secret Recipe Made With Jose Cuervo Tradicional Reposado, Served On The Rocks
SEASONAL
Our Mixologists, Artfully Blend Siete Leguas Tequila With Seasonal Fruit & Citrus
SKINNY DIP
El Jimador Silver, Organic Agave, Lime, Served Straight Up
SPICY MEZCALITA
Tanteo Chipotle, Conejos Mezcal, Lime, With A Smoked Salt Rim
MARGARITAS
BEACHY COCKTAILS
RINCON POINT FROZEN PAINKILLER
Pusser's Navy Rum, OJ, Coconut Cream, Pineapple, Nutmeg & Almond Lucano
MAVERICKS G&T
Grey Whale Cali Gin, London Essence Elderflower & Blood Orange Tonic, Served Tall With Citrus
PISMO’S COOL AS A CUCUMBER
Crop Organic Vodka, Saint Germain Elderflower, English Cucumber, Strawberry & Mint, Served Straight Up
SWAMI’S TAMARINDO
Tamarind Infused Arette Reposado Tequila, Topped With Jarritos Soda & Lime
Betty’s “Beach Blonde” Lager
Pacifico
KCBC “Superhero Sidekick” IPA
Rotating Local Drafts
DRAFTS BEERS
CANS BEERS
Modelo “Esp”
Corona Light, Tecate,
Safety Glasses IPA “NA”
Bohemia, Negra Modelo
Coronita
BOTTLES BEERS
CRAFT BEERS
Cigar City “Jai Ali” IPA
Tenement Pils
Lizard King “Pale Ale”
Allagash White
Brooklyn Cider “Kinda Dry”
Caposaldo Prosecco
BUBBLES
ROSE
Saleya Provence Rose
The Seeker Sauv Blanc
Cali Chardonnay Hess
Salmon Run Riesling
WHITE
RED
The Seeker Pinot Noir
Montes Cabernet Sauv
Alta Vista Arge Malbec
Seasonal Sangria
SANGRIA
Happy Endings
CHURRO ICE CREAM SANDWICH
Creamy Vanilla Gelato
MEXICAN FLAN
Berries, Mezcal Whipped Cream
MANGONADA
Mango Sorbet, Chamoy, Tajin & Berries
SPICY CHOCOLATE BROWNIE
Dulce de leche Ice Cream, Spicy Peanuts, Salted Caramel
Tapatio Blanco
Gran Centenario Plata
El Tesoro Blanco
Espolon Blanco
Herradura Silver
Partida Blanco
Milagro Barrel Select Silver
Casamigos Blanco
Codigo Rosa
BLANCO - THE BEST TEQUILA
REPOSADO - THE BEST TEQUILA
Pueblo Viejo Reposado
Tapatio Reposado
El Tesoro Reposado
Herradura Reposado
Fortaleza Reposado
Viva Reposado
Maestro Dobel Reposado
Partida Reposado
Riazul Reposado
Milagro Barrel Select Reposado
Casamigos Reposado
Clase Azul Reposado
Viva Joven
Maestro Dobel Anejo
Milagro Barrel Select Anejo
Corralejo Anejo Horas
Don Fulano Anejo
Don Julio
Codigo Extra Anejo Origen
Herradura Seleccion Suprema
Casa Dragones Joven
ANEJO & JOVEN - THE BEST TEQUILA
MEZCAL - THE BEST TEQUILA
Noble Espadin
Del Maguey San Luis Del Rio
Del Maguey Wild Tepextate
Del Maguey Pechuga
Mezcales De Leyenda Oaxaca
Los Amantes Añejo
Tosba Pechuga
Clase Azul Mezcal
Noble Coyote
CARAMELIZED PINEAPPLE GINGER FIZZ
Lime, Fever Tree Ginger Beer
CHAMANGO
Fresh Mango Juice, Lime, Chimoy & Tajin Rim
